Wednesday, December 30, 2020

Science, Not Policy

 Pore 'ol Doc Faucci.  It seems that other experts are beginning to question his  statements durin the Covid plague.  No one can doubt that before he was i the public eye, he was a highly respected epidemiologist.  

But, he kept dragging the goalposts up and down the field in an attempt to shift public behavior, first with the advise on wearing masks, and later on the question of herd immunity.

I feel sorry for the guy.  He labored for decades in work that was demanding, important, and generally ignored by the vast majority o  the public sphere.  His work was important, but not of interest to most folks. Then, one day, the President called him and he seemed to be the leading expert on pandemics.  Suddenly, he was in the public eye.  As a respected scientist.  And, in the space of a year, hie ego got the best of him.

Of all the people that no one knew last year, Dr. Deborah Birx  and Dr. Anthony Faucci seem to represent those anonymous scientists that labor for our combined good in near anonymity.  Their reputations were secure and their expertise unquestioned.  Now, a year later, Dr. Birx is retired because she recommended one thing and did something else.  Doc Faucci is now regarded as a policy flack.  Science be damned.

It's a cautionary tale.  In the Army we had a saying, that one aw-shit wipes out a thousand atta-boys.  To her credit, Dr. Birx, when confronted with her hypocrisy, chose to retire with dignity.  We have yet to know how Doc Faucci's career will end, but if other scientists are questioning his judgement, it might be time for him to retire, before he's fired.

1 comment:

BobF said...

I empathize with Dr. Birx -- the old story of one oh shit wipes out all the atta-boys is a product of ignorance and/or jealousy. And her mistake was one of behavior, not one that had any bearing on her work and its results. Bad move, but make a note and carry on.

I am not a fan of Dr. Fauci, however. Yes, his reputation in the medical world is substantial and he brought that to the fore when called. However, I think at some point he fell into the trap of playing politics, a role for which he is/was not well suited. I admit though that being within 10 feet of Trump for extended periods would make not becoming political very difficult. If you stay at the table you're in the game.